What’s The Difference Between Brush Calligraphy And Lettering?
Have you ever wondered about what the difference between hand lettering and calligraphy is?
There’s a lot of terms that get tossed around a lot in the world of lettering. Things like hand lettering, brush calligraphy, typography, and modern calligraphy.
Did you know that they are all different? We’re going to take a closer look at a few of these terms and show you how they differ, and what they usually mean.
By the end you should totally understand the differences and be able to use these terms perfectly.
Please note – This post contains some affiliate links for your convenience, but please know that I do not link to anything that I don’t personally recommend. If you make a purchase after clicking a link I will earn a small commission but it won’t cost you a cent more!
Lettering Verses Calligraphy
Let’s look at the main two first then we will break it down further. So what’s the difference between lettering and calligraphy?
The difference is not the end result, but the process of creation.
The main thing you want to focus on is how it’s made:
Calligraphy is the art of writing letters.
Lettering is the art of drawing letters.
Sometimes the final pieces can look identical and it may be hard to see the difference.
If the words have been sketched, drawn or created in a similar way, then it’s lettering.
If the words have been written using strokes of a pen (or nib & ink) with intention and an artistic purpose then it’s calligraphy.
Hopefully you understand a little bit more about the difference between calligraphy and lettering, let’s go a little bit deeper into each one.
Traditional, Modern, Brush & Digital.
Calligraphy is a visual art form, focused on writing beautifully. It is practiced all over the world with different cultures having their own unique styles, including:
- Chinese Calligraphy
- Western Calligraphy
- Japanese Calligraphy
- Indian Calligraphy
The tools used vary within each culture and may include paint brushes, feather pens, dip pens, ink wells etc.
Unfortunately I’m not educated or trained in any of the cultural calligraphic practices (as much as I would absolutely LOVE to learn something like Indian Calligraphy). So for now let’s focus on Western Calligraphy.
Western Calligraphy uses the latin alphabet and is usually broken down into these options:
- Traditional Calligraphy (also just called calligraphy)
- Modern Calligraphy
- Brush Calligraphy
- Digital Calligraphy
These options look both at how they are created as well as the style of calligraphy.
Traditional calligraphy is usually just called “calligraphy” when comparing it to “modern calligraphy”.
It refers to a style of calligraphy that was used prior to the printing press, when learning to read and write wasn’t commonplace and those that did had strict rules as to what was acceptable.
Traditional Calligraphy refers to styles of calligraphy that have been around for generations.
Copperplate script was widely popular in the 17th and 18th centuries and (like other calligraphy scripts) has very specific rules with regards to how each letter is created, including the strokes, the height & the slant of the letters.
Other traditional calligraphy styles include spencerian, blackletter and roman capitals.
Some traditional calligraphers use traditional tools (such as a dip pen & ink) but some may make use of modern technology (such as brush pens) while still creating the specific calligraphic style using all the traditional rules.
One Thought Regarding the Tools:
There’s an argument about whether traditional calligraphers should stick with traditional tools, and that if you create (for example) perfect copperplate script yet use a brush pen to do so, then you’re not a traditional, but a modern calligrapher.
A dip pen & nib used in calligraphy
Unlike traditional calligraphy, in modern days calligraphers have moved into styles governed by less rules, where calligraphy art has become a form of self-expression.
Often with modern calligraphers their style expresses who they are and have taken the time to fine tune their style.
Some calligraphers also develop multiple styles over time and create full alphabets of different styles that they choose to use depending on the project.
Modern calligraphy tools also vary: some people consider Modern Calligraphy a modern form of traditional calligraphy with regards to style but not tools.
So they use the term “modern calligraphy” for those that still use traditional tools (such as a dip pen and ink) but write in a modern style.
Others say that modern calligraphy can also use modern tools, as long as it’s still calligraphy and not lettering (using the differences we mentioned earlier).
In this regard, Modern Calligraphy would be an umbrella term that also includes the next two topics: Brush Calligraphy & Digital Calligraphy.
This is my passion: brush calligraphy. It is often confused for lettering because the tools that are used (brush pens) are common in both styles.
Brush calligraphy is essentially calligraphy that is created with brush pens.
Japenese Calligraphy (also called shodo) is the artistic writing of the Japanese language. Japense calligraphy was traditionally created with a brush (fude) dipped in a mix of a ground ink stick and water.
Why am I telling you about Japense calligraphy?
Purely because we have them to thank for brush pens. Over time their tools morphed from ground ink and water into bottled liquid ink (bokujū) and brushes, and then further into brush pens (fude pen).
Some of the best and popular brush pens I have found come from Japanese companies. In fact, Kuretake (a Japanese brand) launched the first brush pen in 1973.
Different brush pens I use in brush calligraphy.
In short, brush calligraphy in the western society is where an artist creates beautiful modern calligraphic art using a brush pen.
I wasn’t sure whether or not to add this one, since it’s a topic that’s often up for debate.
Digital calligraphy is where the artist uses digital tools (like an ipad & and the pen stylus) to create calligraphy. It’s purely about what is used to create rather than the style of what is created.
Artists can use digital technologies to create “paintings” that look remarkably like brush strokes, yet they never touch paint or a paint brush. They can create art that looks like it has texture and depth yet it’s all flat and digital.
In saying this, if an artist uses modern tools (such as the ipad and the pen) to create calligraphic strokes, an alphabet and flourishes that can be undone with a double tap, is it still calligraphy?
I like to think so, therefore, I like to use the term “digital calligraphy” for this, not to be mixed up with digital lettering.
This calligraphy was created with the Ipad, the Procreate App using the Apple Pen.
Hand Lettering & Digital Lettering
As mentioned earlier lettering differs to calligraphy in the way it is created. Lettering is a process which includes things like sketching, outlining, inking, adding embellishments (such as shadows).
Lettering can create some really diverse and incredible artworks.
I am not a letterer. I enjoy trying it, I would like to learn more, but I don’t consider myself a letterer.
One of my all time favourite letterers are Stefan Kunz and Ian Barnard.
The thing with proficient letterers (such as Stefan and Ian) is you can bet your bottom dollar that they are trained in calligraphy & typography also.
It seems to be truly good at lettering it’s important to understand calligraphic styles and have a good understanding of typographic elements.
True letterers draw from all of this knowledge to create artworks that capture the attention of the viewer and can honestly sometimes take your breath away.
There’s three terms that get tossed around a lot and they are:
- Hand Lettering
- Digital Lettering
Often you will see Lettering and Hand Lettering often interchanged. Here are what I have found that seems to be the common definitions:
Lettering: An umbrella term that encompasses both hand lettering and digital lettering. This term also included lettering that started as hand lettering and then digitsed.
Hand Lettering: Lettering that is specifically done without digital technology, including digitisation.
Digital Lettering: Lettering that was created with the use of an Ipad, computer or other digital technology.
An Example of Digital Lettering. Photo by Elena Mozhvilo on Unsplash
Another term I see floating around (not as often though) is Brush Lettering.
Brush lettering simply means lettering that is created initially using brush pens but then embellishments are added to it after (such as shadows, borders & highlights) in order to turn it into lettering and not calligraphy.
Brush lettering seems to be widely popular amongst bullet journallers, university students (to make their study notes beautiful) and those who are just starting in the calligraphy & lettering world.
Calligraphy Verses Typography
Typography is the art of using words/letters.
It’s not as much of a “fine art form” as lettering or calligraphy anymore but nowadays typography is more about learning the fundamentals rules and information behind arranging words, letters, numbers and symbols for publication or display.
Some careers that incorporate typography into their training & use are:
- Graphic Designers
- Art directors
- Manga & Comic Book Artists
- Clothing design
- Industrial Designers
As I mentioned earlier those who are highly skilled in advanced lettering usually have a great understanding of the elements of typography as they use these elements to make their lettering pieces artistic.
So as you can see typography varies greatly from calligraphy and lettering yet an understanding of all 3 is evident in letterers.
Cursive Verses Calligraphy
Modern calligraphy often gets mistaken for cursive or handwriting. This is understandable because calligraphy is the art of writing letters, so it makes sense that some people would think that pretty handwriting is a form of calligraphy.
Modern calligraphy doesn’t abide by as many rules as traditional calligraphic styles used to, yet there are some that remain. These foundations and elements still need to be adhered to somewhat to keep it as calligraphy.
Things like “downstrokes are always thicker and upstrokes are thinner”.
Although it depends upon the type of calligraphy, and because it is an art form, it the necessity of these “rules” may be subjective.
Moreso, though, the differences in cursive and calligraphy are more “behind the scenes”.
What’s your intention? Are you indending it to be an art form or are you intending it to be for function (eg, a grocery shopping list). Is this going to be on display? Are you creating something that you want others to be seeing and admiring/critiquing?
What level of speed and detail are you doing? Are you purposely going slow to make each detail pretty, or are you writing fast like you would when you’re taking notes? Are you focusing on the connections between the letters and keeping them consistent or are you ok with just getting it done and however they turn out?
If you look at these questions honestly then you may be able to examine the writing as either calligraphy or cursive.
How Do I Learn Calligraphy & Lettering?
Now I couldn’t explain all these differences and just bail before I give you some resources. If you would like to learn, here’s some things you can check out:
Brush Calligraphy Fundamentals Book by Cherry Pearl Creative
Modern Dip Pen Calligraphy:
The Postman’s Knock – a terrific resource full of freebies and articles
Traditional Dip Pen Calligraphy:
Mastering Copperplate Calligraphy: A Step-By-Step Manual by Eleanor Winters
Let’s Start Lettering Course by Amanda Arneill
Hopefully this has made it all a little clearer and you can now understand what kind of artform it is when you see beautiful writing.